Home Catholicism

Catholicism

Criticisms for Allowing

Criticisms for Allowing

As in the instance of many controversial topics, exist numerous criticisms against the practice of a marriage annulment. A common argument refers to societal norms. People are more individualistic in modern times, women are more independent, thus creating a societal leniency towards divorce and annulments. Individuals in marriage find loopholes and ambiguous reasons for annulment. The second argument which goes in hand in hand with social implications is the modern interpretation of annulment law. 
Further criticism on the part of the general public illustrates the Criticism of annulment includes the Catholic church and the implications that it carries. Obviously when annulment law was written centuries ago, the policy makers could not predict the complexity and diversity of our society today. It is only logical that such an archaic law would have deficiencies when applied to contemporary times. Reasons for annulment have not evolved as society has. Spousal abuse for instance is looked at today with great disgust and held in utter contempt. That being said, it is still not a suitable reason for annulment under the canon law. If a devout Catholic is in an abusive relationship she would have no means to end her marriage. In order to adapt to modern day beliefs and policies there has to be innovations, unfortunately for annulment law, policies have been left unchanged.
Many devout Catholics who have substantial reasons for annulment choose divorce instead to save considerable amounts of time. As divorce rates skyrocket past 50% the sanctity of marriage has clearly been put into question. The logic of waiting 14 months to uphold this divine sense is nonsensical to many. The time is a particularly important issue because the Catholic church does not allow a re-marriage during a pending annulment verdict. 
During that 14 months, if one finds someone they would want to marry, they would have to wait till the pending annulment is granted. Annulment law restricts its users greatly, it restricts them from making decisions in their personal life. Reasons for annulment vary as do consequences but to the church they are placed under the same umbrella. It is nearly impossible to uphold annulment law, which was written thousands of years ago, while adapting to an ever changing society.

What Are The Catholicism Implications

What Are The Catholicism Implications

In consideration of the process dissolves a marriage, and deems the wedding
fictitious, there are numerous implications to be aware of after obtaining a Catholic
marriage annulment. The most tangible
revolves around assets and children
. Like
divorce, a Catholic marriage annulment will split finances, debts, and children
appropriately. This often times comes with great conflict, for it is a lengthy
and emotional process. Based on competence and willingness of the individual
spouses in question, the rights, child support payments, and visitation will
all be settled by the Church tribunal.

        
Catholic
marriage annulments also place restrictions on those seeking a decree of
nullity following a divorce. Considering the church does not recognize divorce
as a means to disrupt the sacred bond, a Catholic marriage annulment must be
obtained in order to remarry in the Church. Basic church rights will still
exist if a previous marriage was never voided: communion, confirmation, and the
ability to raise a family in the Catholic church will all be upheld. In order
to better define the Catholic marriage annulment one must understand the
intricacies of the marital contract.

        
Most
grounds for annulment under the church revolve around violations of church law.
Catholics consider marriage to be a sacred unity; consummation, fidelity, and
eternity are many of the stipulations that this holy bond possesses. If one of
the spouses fails to meet these requirements than grounds for annulment are
met. In addition to these violations, Catholics must be united in front of a
priest or deacon. If vows are not exchanged at the hand of a priest, deacon or
in front of at least two witnesses grounds for annulment are also achieved.

        
Catholic
marriage annulments do not focus nor permit decrees of nullity to marriages
that simply desire them. Unlike divorce, a specific violation must be present
for grounds for annulment to be met. The Catholic views of a marriage revolve
around the basic principles of the religion. For instance, Catholics view the
creation of life as the essence for our being and society. A marriage is a
joining of a husband and wife so that procreation is possible. If the marriage
is not consummated there is no point to receiving the sacrament. That being
said, if one of the partners is unable to give birth or produce life, then
grounds for annulment are justified. In addition to life, the sacred bond that
marriage creates is something that no man can divide. The uniting is spiritual
and emotional, a divorce may separate possessions and wealth, but it does not
disrupt the eternal bond. If infidelity is present, and a spouse makes it known
that there was no intention to remain faithful grounds for annulment are
reached. 


A Catholic marriage annulment erases a bond from ever existing, but it does so
by finding some sort of fault within the marriage. It is a unique tool that can
offer closure and clarity, which leads to a Catholic justification to maintain
the sanctity of the marriage covenant, but also offer those who happen to make
mistakes during the process a chance to amend.

Easy Guide to Annulment Catholicism

Easy Guide to Annulment Catholicism

Background
The history of annulment is rich with Biblical passages and reference to theocratic doctrine. Countless allusions to the hopes, practices, processes, and expectations of marriage are laid out in Canon law,marriage to be not only sanctified, but also immutable, prior to any legal statutes constructed regarding the processes and practices of terminating a marriage, the notion of divorce did not exist. However, due to the establishment of the United States as a democratic nation, the rules and legislatures that have been solidified are rooted in the interest of the citizens, not in any religious institution. Although a citizen of the United States may choose to exist in a religious spectrum, both religious canon, as well as dogma,conflicts found in the annulment process.
 
Implications
As is in the case of any perennial doctrine, without amendments and modifications based on the needs and circumstances of modernity, such a doctrine is subject to an assumed status of tradition. Had the Constitution of the United States disallowed for amendments, the ability of a citizen’s adherence to the laws expressed in its text would be difficult, if not unacceptable. Without the amendments to the Constitution, everyday practices occurring in the United States would still include such atrocities as slavery, discrimination, and possibly tyranny. 
In order to avoid a similar fate, the Catholic church established church tribunals, which are appointed to rule over cases that involve both secular and religious matters. In order to both better provide for their followers, as well as retain the ability to exist within a democratic society, the Catholic church established this tribunal with the hopes of providing the best possible counsel that fuses legality with faith. Although the Catholic church does not recognize the act of divorce, they wished to provide their followers of faith with the availability of an annulment; annulment allows for a church-sanctioned termination of marriage. Many detractors of the process of annulment have criticized its methods as archaic, as a result of their perception of religious dogma valued over ethics and human rights.
Process
As a citizen of the United States , a democratic nation,legal counsel. Should a decision allowing the annulment be reached, the couple is urged to reconsider the termination of the marriage for 14 months; in addition, any subsequent marriages on the parts of the couple in question will not be recognizable by the Catholic church.
 

Criticisms for Allowing
The act of pursuing an annulment of marriage is an individual choice made by either member , or both members , of the couple in question. Akin to the couple’s desire to conduct their lives in a manner that values religious tenets, the choice to adhere to the practices and processes of annulment are matters of volition. However, due to the inherent contradiction of the integration of religious ideals in tandem with legislation , as per the First Amendment to the Constitution, many detractors call the validity of annulment into question. Yet, pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment, which allows every citizen of the United States to their own life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness,custody of children, in a legal forum, the details and history of the marriage oftentimes dictate both the disbursement of property, as well as the custodial rights of the parents.